Manchester United's Struggles Exposed: Tactical Failures in 3-0 Loss to Spurs

Manchester United’s ongoing struggles under Erik ten Hag were laid bare during their 3-0 defeat to Tottenham Hotspur, highlighting significant issues both on and off the ball. Despite expectations of a spirited response after recent performances, United appeared disjointed and lacking in determination.

In the first half, United’s inability to maintain possession was troubling, but their failure to defend effectively was even more concerning. Ten Hag’s team seemed to lack the hunger and organization necessary to compete at this level. After a disappointing Europa League draw against Twente, where Ten Hag admitted the opposition “wanted it more,” fans hoped to see a more fired-up United against Spurs. Unfortunately, that spirit was missing.

United’s approach featured Bruno Fernandes and Joshua Zirkzee playing as false nines, aimed at preventing midfield dominance by Spurs. However, this tactic backfired early on, as they relinquished control to Tottenham’s back four. Good positioning and determination are vital, yet United failed to win crucial duels, track runners, or recognize danger effectively.

The first goal came just minutes into the match, stemming from a lack of defensive pressure on Micky van de Ven. His powerful run went unchecked, and Diogo Dalot’s momentary lapse allowed Brennan Johnson to score from a well-placed cross. After conceding, United lost their composure, struggling to reclaim the ball and maintain defensive organization. By the time Bruno Fernandes received a controversial red card before half-time, Spurs could have already sealed the game.

While Tottenham’s attacking philosophy, led by manager Ange Postecoglou, rewarded them for their adventurous play, United seemed lost. They are currently without key striker Rasmus Hojlund, which has forced them to adjust their formation. Despite some chances created, their patterns of play appear tentative and lacking confidence.

One potential area for improvement is the defense. Frequent changes in the lineup have hindered cohesion among players. For instance, centre-backs Matthijs de Ligt and Lisandro Martinez had only started together three times prior to the match. As players become more accustomed to one another, their performance may improve, but the mindset remains a pressing concern.

Ten Hag did manage to inspire a more aggressive approach in the second half after introducing Casemiro and Mason Mount. United pressed higher up the pitch, putting Spurs under pressure and creating opportunities. However, the question lingers: why did it take going down to ten men for the team to show that level of fight and determination?

As United prepares for upcoming matches, Ten Hag must address these issues and instill a more consistent and tenacious mindset in his squad.