Drew Barrymore Reveals Original Dark Ending of ‘50 First Dates’ and Why It Was Changed

Drew Barrymore recently took a nostalgic trip down memory lane, shedding light on the original, darker ending of the beloved 2004 romantic comedy 50 First Dates. On a recent episode of her daytime talk show, the 49-year-old actress, who starred as Lucy Whitmore opposite Adam Sandler’s Henry Roth, shared intriguing details about the film’s initial concept and conclusion.

Barrymore revealed that 50 First Dates was originally conceived as a drama set in Seattle, under the working title 50 First Kisses. The film, which ultimately takes place in the sunny setting of Hawaii, tells the story of Lucy, a woman suffering from short-term memory loss, and Henry, a marine veterinarian who falls deeply in love with her. Despite the comedic and heartwarming tone of the final cut, Barrymore’s disclosure about the original storyline paints a starkly different picture.

In the initial draft of the script, the ending took a much more somber turn. Barrymore explained that the original conclusion featured Lucy telling Henry, “You should go and live your life because this is no life here.” According to her, Henry would then leave, only to return and sit down at a restaurant, introducing himself with the line, “Hi, I’m Henry.” The film would have ended on this unresolved note, highlighting a more melancholic and poignant resolution.

Barrymore’s co-host, Ross Mathews, was visibly shocked by the revelation, expressing his gratitude for the change in direction. “Honestly, can I just tell you: Thank you. Thank you for changing it,” Mathews said, reflecting the sentiment of many fans who appreciated the film’s more uplifting conclusion.

50 First Dates was a notable collaboration between Barrymore and Sandler, marking their second film together following The Wedding Singer (1998) and preceding their 2014 reunion in Blended. Their on-screen chemistry has been widely praised, and in a March 2023 interview with People magazine, Barrymore spoke candidly about their bond. She described their relationship as one built on “love, admiration, and humor,” emphasizing that their professional collaborations stem from a deep mutual respect and affection.

In December 2023, Barrymore hinted at the possibility of a sequel to 50 First Dates during a discussion about which romantic comedy she would like to remake. The idea of revisiting the beloved characters has sparked interest among fans, who have long cherished the heartwarming story of Henry and Lucy.

Barrymore’s insights into the original ending of 50 First Dates provide a fascinating look at how creative decisions can significantly alter the emotional impact of a film. While the original ending would have delivered a more bittersweet conclusion, the final version has remained a cherished romantic comedy, thanks to its heartwarming and hopeful resolution.